
The decision keeps in place a system that lets students remain as long as they meet the terms of their studies.
The rule would have set admission periods of no more than four years for students with F visas and exchange visitors with J visas. Those who needed more time would have had to ask the government to extend their stays.
U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV set aside the entire rule under the Administrative Procedure Act. He ruled for the education groups and labor unions that sued and rejected the request from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) for judgment in its favor.
DHS Exceeded Authority
The judge found that DHS failed to properly weigh the rule’s costs against its benefits. The judge also found that the agency failed to explain how the changes would address fraud and national security threats, consider less costly options, or fully answer key public comments.
The rule’s limits on academic choices also went beyond the power Congress gave DHS, according to the order. Saylor found that those limits worked against the F-1 visa program’s goal of allowing foreign students to study in the United States. For example, the rule could block a student from earning business and engineering degrees together.
“The statute simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program,” Saylor wrote.
Tighter Visa Checks
“By implementing clear, finite limits on these visas, the United States is reclaiming its ability to properly screen, vet, and monitor individuals within our borders,” Mullin said in a July statement.
The judge found that DHS had not fully weighed whether it could improve its existing student tracking system instead. Schools already must report students’ addresses, coursework and academic standing, and they can lose permission to enroll foreign students if they fail to follow reporting rules.
DHS argued that the database collects school reports rather than decides immigration status. Saylor found that the agency had not shown how a new renewal process after four years would better uncover fraud or justify its costs.
The four-year limit would have forced nearly all doctoral students to seek more time, according to that earlier ruling. Decisions denying extensions would have been left to DHS officials, with no right to appeal.
Foreign journalists with I visas also would have faced a 240-day admission limit, according to the September ruling. Those needing longer stays would have had to seek extensions.
Saylor paused the rule Sept. 14, a day before it was set to take effect.
